7 min read
Major Takeaways
- A judge agreed Tuesday there was not enough evidence against Earnest Lloyd Jr. to proceed.
- Prosecutors said the case was not ready to be presented to a grand jury.
- Police in Jackson must now investigate the Fortune killing further.
- Her mother, Christy Spivey, called the police work sloppy and seeks an investigation.
- Eric Clark and Jarques Ratliff still face murder charges in the same case.
The case against one of the men charged in the death of Tasia Fortune is going back to the drawing board.
A Hinds County judge ruled Tuesday that the evidence against Earnest Lloyd Jr. is not enough to move forward.
The ruling sends Jackson police back to investigate a killing that has haunted this city since August.
Fortune was 29 years old and a mother of four children.
Readers can follow the case from its start in our earlier Tasia Fortune report and in our News section.

What Happened at the Tasia Fortune Hearing
Hinds County Judge Johnnie McDaniels agreed Tuesday that there was not enough evidence against Lloyd to proceed.
He remanded the case against Lloyd to Jackson Municipal Court.
Jackson police detectives will now conduct further investigation into the charges against him.
Prosecutors told the court Tuesday the case against Lloyd was not ready for a grand jury.
Details about the specific evidence tied to Lloyd never came out in open court Tuesday.
Lloyd himself was not in the courtroom for the hearing.
He was in transit from a jail in northern Mississippi when the judge ruled.
He had been held at the Tallahatchie Correctional Facility.
He was set to move to the Hinds County Detention Center.
The court also learned his lawyer had not yet been able to speak with him.
His lawyer is Nicholas Coleman.
State Public Defender Andre de Gruy said his office does not represent Lloyd.
De Gruy said a case with too little evidence at this stage should be dismissed without prejudice.
He said Lloyd should be released while the investigation continues.
He added that charges could be filed again at a later date.
Reports of the hearing did not say Lloyd had been released from custody.
Jackson police spokesman Tommie Brown declined to comment on the decision.
A Mother Calls the Police Work Sloppy
Christy Spivey said the ruling did not surprise her at all.
Spivey is the mother of Tasia Fortune.
She told reporters she believes Jackson police withheld evidence in the case.
She said the department gave the family few answers, if any.
She described the handling of the case by police as “sloppy.”
“You can’t get anything,” Spivey said. “Nobody tells you anything.”
She said the department has not answered or returned family calls recently.
She said the internal affairs office never responded to her inquiries.
Spivey has started a petition calling for an investigation into the department.
She said she wants to rebuild her relationship with Jackson police.
She also said her trust in the department is eroding.
She is unsure that trust can be restored, she said.
The department declined to issue a statement in response to her comments.
For families across Jackson, that silence is its own kind of pain.

How Police Say Tasia Fortune Died
Fortune was found dead on August 3 behind a vacant home in west Jackson.
The home sits in the 500 block of Road of Remembrance.
Police said a black cable cord was used to hang her from a tree.
Investigators believe she was killed at another location first.
They believe her body was then placed in a hanging position to stage the scene.
Police believe she had been dead for two to three days when she was found.
Authorities have confirmed the manner of death was homicide.
They have not announced a specific cause of death.
They have not said whether she was strangled, beaten, or stabbed.
Police allege she was killed after a dispute over missing illegal narcotics.
Investigators allege she had been suspected of taking the drugs.
Detective Samuel Dukes testified on September 30 about the final days of her life.
Dukes said Jarques Ratliff acted as an enforcer directed to kill Fortune.
He said Ratliff and Fortune had been friends and intimate with each other.
He testified they lured her into a vehicle in late July to “hit a lick.”
He said Ratliff and Clark came back with a pocket full of money and drugs.
Fortune never came back at all.
Store video showed Fortune alive on July 28, Dukes testified.
A witness told police she last saw Fortune on July 30 or July 31.
Why This Death Still Haunts Jackson
The image of a Black woman hanging from a tree carries a terror all its own in Mississippi.
Her death stoked fears she had been targeted because of her race.
It conjured memories of lynching and racial terror across the South.
All three men charged in the case are Black, police have said.
Police say props were left at the scene as part of the staging.
Chief RaShall Brackney said that fear has damaged the whole community.
“We know we have a very sordid history around lynchings and racial terror across this nation and particularly around the South,” Brackney said.
“That is still a very current narrative. It is still a very raw narrative,” she said.
Judge Jeffery Reynolds set bond for Clark at $5 million after his arrest in late September.
Reynolds called the killing heinous from the bench.
“People justifiably did not know if we had a killer on the loose who might hang people for racial reasons,” Reynolds said.
The wider pattern across the South keeps families on edge.
In the past two years, about six Black women and men have been found hanged across the South.
None of those deaths has been found to be criminal.
Critics say officers in some cases moved fast to label the deaths suicides.
They say that rush came before evidence could rule out foul play.
Long before any arrest, Spivey said she did not believe race drove the death of her daughter.
Spivey is white, and she said the father of Fortune is Black.
“I think this is something very personal, very personal,” Spivey said.
She insisted someone who knew Fortune was involved.
After a September hearing for Ratliff, Clark hugged Spivey at the courthouse.
“He never said he did it, but he said he was there to turn himself in for murder,” Spivey told reporters.
What Happens Next for Clark, Ratliff, and Lloyd
Eric Clark, age 45, remains held on a murder charge in the case.
Jarques Ratliff, age 51, also remains held on a murder charge.
Clark and Ratliff have pleaded not guilty, as has Lloyd.
A charge is not a conviction in this or any case.
Each man is presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.
Brackney told reporters in late September that more arrests were expected.
No new arrests had been announced when Tuesday ended.
Now the burden shifts back to the detectives who built this case.
They must find the evidence a judge found missing on Tuesday.
They must also answer a mother who says her calls go unreturned.
The pain of families waiting on answers also runs through our Azalea Drive shooting coverage in Jackson.
Tasia Fortune was a daughter, a mother of four, and a woman who deserved to come home.
Jackson still owes her family a case built on evidence strong enough to stand.
Urban City Podcast will follow every hearing until this family gets real answers.














